Switch to an accessible version of this website which is easier to read. (requires cookies)

A political trauma, but a policy success” – the FT’s verdict on tuition fees

January 3, 2012 11:18 AM
By Nick Thornsby in Liberal Democrat Voice
Originally published by East Midlands Liberal Democrats

One year on from what remains, for many Liberal Democrats, the most traumatic decision yet taken by the coalition, the FT (via an editorial in the newspaper) has provided its assessment of the policy.

Here's what the newspaper says on the policy itself:

Many academics and students continue to grumble about the move to charge undergraduates for their tuition costs. But governments looking for ways to reduce their outgoings should consider raising such charges - so long as they do it fairly, as the UK has.

It is a big concern that high college fees - and the fear of them - prevent middle class families in the US from getting the most out of higher education. Even where generous support exists, it can be difficult to understand.

This is a problem: it is a hallmark of an open, liberal society that class, privilege and prestige should not be hereditary. If charging more meant that poor children turned into poor adults, it would not be acceptable.

But governments cannot simply ladle cash out to universities - not least because good universities should answer to students, not finance ministers. In any case, the main beneficiaries of education are the people who receive it: they really ought to pay.

There is a way to square the circle. The UK government uses a method of funding universities whose principles could profitably be replicated around the world - the so-called "income contingent loan". UK students are all eligible for a state loan, so none must find cash up-front. Repayments are due only when graduates can afford it. If they fall out of work or take a low-paid job, the repayments are paused and the interest rate drops.

And here's what the newspaper says about the role the Liberal Democrats played in taking the decision:

Sadly, support for raising tuition fees has been toxic for the Liberal Democrats, who dropped their admittedly overly strident pre-election opposition to the policy. The party's poll ratings, which had been in the 20s before the May election, crumbled throughout 2010 to a plateau of about 10 points.

Most of these voters had probably abandoned the Lib Dems before the controversy over tuition fees. But the reversal on student fees has damaged Nick Clegg, party leader, especially among the rank-and-file. (It is not obvious that the Conservative leadership has made a sacrifice of similar size for the coalition)

The FT's conclusion:

Voters may not thank them for it, but the fee and loan system is a policy legacy of which the Lib Dems can be proud. In an age of political timidity, Nick Clegg's decision was correct - and courageous.

You can find the whole piece here.

What would you like to do next?

  • Subscribe for updates

    Read updates from this website in your desktop or online news reader

    • On a news reader website

      •  
      •  
      •  

      In a desktop news reader or a website not listed above

      •  
    • Example monthly digest email
      •  
      •  
      •  
    • If you submit your contact details, the Liberal Democrats and their elected representatives may use the information you provide to contact you about issues you may find of interest. Some of the contacts may be automated. You can opt out of these contacts at any time by contacting


    • Generate different image

    Join our email list

    • If you submit your contact details, the Liberal Democrats and their elected representatives may use the information you provide to contact you about issues you may find of interest. Some of the contacts may be automated. You can opt out of these contacts at any time by contacting


    • Generate different image

    Follow the party's activity on...

  • Share this page

    Share this page on another website

    Link to this page

    On websites and printed material:
    midderbyshirelibdems.org.uk/en/article/2012/546876/a-political-trauma-but-a-policy-success-the-ft-s-verdict-on-tuition-fees-1
    In text messages, Twitter, or reading over the phone:
    midderbyshirelibdems.org.uk/a6rJh

    Email this page to a friend


    • Generate different image
  • Help out or donate

    Help out in your local area

      •  
      •  
      •  
      •  
      •  
      •  
      •  
      •  
      •  
      •  
      •  
      •  
    • If you submit your contact details, the Liberal Democrats and their elected representatives may use the information you provide to contact you about issues you may find of interest. Some of the contacts may be automated. You can opt out of these contacts at any time by contacting


    • Generate different image
  • Tell us what you think

    Send us your views

    • If you agree, the Liberal Democrats and their elected representatives may use the information you provide to contact you about issues you may find of interest. Some of the contacts may be automated. You can opt out of these contacts at any time by contacting us.


    • Generate different image